The Ultimate Guide to Finding a Dog Sitter You Can Trust: Expert Tips From 15+ years of Dog Care Experience

How to Find a Dog Sitter You Can Actually Trust Before You Travel
By The Single, Sick, and Broke Traveler

One of the biggest reasons people delay or cancel a vacation isn't money, transportation, or even their health.

It's guilt.

If you're anything like me, your dog isn't "just a pet." They're family. Leaving them behind can feel heartbreaking, especially if they're older, anxious, have medical needs, or simply sleep on your pillow every night.

After more than 15 years as a professional dog sitter, I've learned that the biggest difference between a relaxing vacation and a stressful one usually comes down to one thing:

Finding the right person—not just the cheapest person—to care for your best friend.

Here's what I recommend before you pack your suitcase.

Start Looking Early

The best dog sitters are often booked weeks or even months in advance, especially during holidays and summer travel.

Waiting until the last minute usually means you'll have fewer choices and may have to settle for someone you don't completely trust.

As soon as you book your trip, start searching for pet care.

Decide What Type of Care Your Dog Needs

Every dog is different.

Ask yourself:
- Does my dog do better staying at home?
- Would they enjoy staying with another family?
- Do they need medication?
- Are they afraid of storms or fireworks?
- Are they elderly?
- Do they have separation anxiety?
- Are they reactive around other dogs?

The more honest you are about your dog's personality, the easier it will be to find the right sitter.

Ask Lots of Questions

A good dog sitter welcomes questions.

Don't be afraid to ask:
- How long have you been caring for dogs?
- Are you insured or bonded?
- Can you provide references?
- How many visits do you make each day?
- What happens during an emergency?
- Have you cared for senior or special-needs dogs?
- Will my dog ever be left alone for long periods?

If someone seems irritated by your questions, keep looking.

Schedule a Meet-and-Greet

Never hire someone without meeting them first. I recommend you bring your dog so both you and your pup can get familiar with the surroundings.

Watch how they interact with your dog.

Does your dog seem relaxed?

Does the sitter get down on your dog's level?

Do they ask questions about routines, feeding, medications, favorite toys, allergies and fears?

The best dog sitters want to know everything because they understand every dog is unique.

Leave Detailed Instructions

Even experienced pet sitters appreciate written instructions.

Include:
- Feeding schedule
- Portion sizes
- Medication instructions
- Emergency contacts
- Veterinarian information
- Favorite walking route
- Bedtime routine
- House rules
- Alarm codes (if necessary)
- Wi-Fi password (if applicable)

The more information you provide, the easier it is to keep your dog's routine consistent.

Prepare an Emergency Plan

Hope for the best, but plan for the unexpected.

Leave:
- Your travel itinerary
- Hotel information
- Flight details
- An emergency contact who can make decisions if you're unreachable
- A credit card on file with your veterinarian if possible

Knowing there's a backup plan provides peace of mind for everyone involved.

Request Daily Updates

One of the greatest gifts a dog sitter can give you is reassurance. I personally send daily videos for my clients so they can see how their pups are doing. Videos give parents a better grasp on their pups' wellbeing than a simple text and/or photo. So ask your potential sitter how they say in contact.

Ask for:
- Daily photos
- Short videos
- Text updates
- Notes about eating, drinking, and bathroom habits

A happy video of your dog can make your entire vacation more relaxing.

Trust Your Instincts

If something doesn't feel right, don't ignore it.

The right sitter will make you feel comfortable before you even leave home.

You should never feel pressured into hiring someone you're unsure about.

Before You Walk Out the Door

Take one last walk with your dog.

Spend a few quiet minutes together.

Leave one of your worn T-shirts or blankets with your scent.

Then take a deep breath

Dogs are incredibly resilient, and when they're cared for by someone trustworthy, they usually settle into their routine much faster than we expect.

Travel should bring joy—not worry.

When you know your best friend is safe, loved, and cared for, you're finally able to enjoy the adventure you've worked so hard to plan.

As someone who's spent over 15 years caring for other people's dogs, I can tell you this:

The families who enjoyed their vacations the most weren't the ones who had the fanciest hotels or the biggest travel budgets.

They were the ones who knew their dog was in loving hands.

And that's priceless.

Travel Reflection

Every journey is easier when you know your heart is safe back home. Taking the time to choose the right dog sitter isn't just another item on your travel checklist—it's an investment in your own peace of mind. Your adventure should be filled with new memories, not constant worry. When your four-legged family member is happy, safe, and loved, you can truly enjoy the freedom to explore the world—your way.

Visit Before You Book: What to Look for in a Dog Sitter's Home or Boarding Facility

Whether your dog will be staying in someone's home or at a boarding facility, never be afraid to ask for a tour. A reputable pet care provider should be happy to show you where your dog will eat, sleep, play, and spend their day.

As you walk through the property, trust your senses. Does the space smell reasonably clean? While a home or kennel with dogs will never smell like fresh flowers, it also shouldn't have a strong odor of urine or feces. Floors, bedding, food bowls, and water dishes should appear clean and well maintained. The entire environment should feel organized, safe, and comfortable.

Take a few minutes to simply observe the dogs already in their care. Do they look happy, relaxed, and comfortable around the caregivers? Are tails wagging? Do the staff members speak calmly and kindly, or are they yelling, rushing, or handling the dogs roughly? Dogs often tell you everything you need to know about a place by the way they respond to the people caring for them.

If the dogs have access to outdoor areas, inspect the grounds carefully. Fences should be sturdy and secure, gates should latch properly, and the yard should be free of obvious hazards like broken equipment, toxic plants, or sharp objects. Fresh water should always be available, and there should be shaded areas where dogs can cool off during warm weather.

Don't hesitate to ask where dogs sleep at night, how often they're let outside, how much exercise they receive, and whether they're supervised during playtime. If your dog has special needs, ask how medications are given, how emergencies are handled, and whether someone is available overnight if needed.

Finally, pay attention to how the caregiver interacts with you. Do they listen carefully to your concerns? Do they ask thoughtful questions about your dog's personality, routines, fears, and medical history? The best pet sitters know that every dog is different, and they want to learn as much as possible before your pet ever walks through the door.

Remember, you're not being picky—you're being a responsible pet parent. A quality dog sitter or boarding facility will appreciate your questions because they understand that trust is earned, not assumed. When you leave for your trip, you deserve to feel confident that your best friend is in safe, loving, and capable hands.

Confessions from a Dog Sitter: 10 Things I Wish Every Pet Parent Knew

After more than 15 years of caring for other people's dogs, I've learned that the happiest dogs usually have one thing in common: their owners helped prepare them before they ever walked through the door.

Here are ten things I wish every pet parent knew before leaving their dog with a sitter or boarding facility.

1. Schedule a Practice Visit

If possible, bring your dog for a short visit before your vacation. A few hours—or even a daytime play visit—can help your dog become familiar with the new environment, the smells, and the people. When vacation day arrives, they'll recognize the place instead of feeling like they've been left somewhere completely unfamiliar. When your dog is dropped off, pups are often anxious. But if they've been to the place before, it will help your baby adjust better.

2. Tell Us Everything

You know your dog better than anyone else, and no detail is too small.

Tell us if your dog:
- Is afraid of thunderstorms.
- Hides during fireworks.
- Guards food or toys.
- Gets nervous around men, children, or other dogs.
- Loves belly rubs before bedtime.
- Has favorite toys or routines.
- Needs medication or supplements.
- Has allergies or a sensitive stomach.

The more we know, the better we can care for your best friend.

3. Don't Change Their Food Right Before Vacation

Vacation is already stressful for many dogs. Changing their food at the same time can upset their stomach and make them uncomfortable. Pack enough of their regular food for the entire stay, plus a little extra in case your travel plans change.

4. Bring Something That Smells Like Home

A favorite blanket, bed, or even an old T-shirt you've worn can be incredibly comforting. Familiar scents help dogs feel safe when they're missing their family.

5. Leave Clear Written Instructions

Even if you've explained everything in person, write it down. Feeding schedules, medication times, emergency contacts, your veterinarian's information, and your dog's daily routine are easy to forget during a busy drop-off.

6. Don't Rush the Goodbye

Your dog notices your emotions. Stay calm, give them a hug, tell them you'll be back, and leave confidently. Long, emotional goodbyes can make some dogs more anxious.

7. Make Sure Identification Is Current

Double-check that your dog's ID tags and microchip information are up to date before you travel. It's a simple step that provides extra peace of mind.

8. Be Honest About Behavior Challenges

If your dog jumps fences, chews shoes, barks all night, or has separation anxiety, please tell your sitter. We're not there to judge—we're there to keep your dog safe.

9. Keep Communication Open

Most professional sitters are happy to send updates and photos. Let them know how often you'd like to hear from them, and don't hesitate to check in if you're worried.

10. Remember That Your Dog Is Adjusting, Too

Some dogs settle in within minutes. Others may need a day or two to relax and feel at home. That's perfectly normal. A patient, experienced sitter understands this and will help your dog adjust with kindness and consistency.

From One Dog Lover to Another

One of the greatest gifts you can give your dog isn't an expensive toy or gourmet treats—it's thoughtful preparation. When you choose a caring sitter, share honest information, and help your dog become comfortable before your trip, you're setting them up for success.

As a dog sitter, I've always wanted every pet parent to enjoy their vacation without constantly worrying about what was happening back home. The more prepared everyone is, the happier the experience becomes—for you, your dog, and the person caring for them.

Because the goal isn't simply finding someone to watch your dog.

It's finding someone who will care for them like family until you return.

10 Red Flags That Should Make You Walk Away

Finding the right dog sitter is about more than convenience—it's about your pet's safety and well-being. If something doesn't feel right during your visit, trust your instincts. Here are ten warning signs that should make you think twice before leaving your furry family member behind.

1. They Won't Let You Tour the Property

A trustworthy sitter or boarding facility has nothing to hide. If you're told you can't see where your dog will be staying, eating, or exercising, consider it a major warning sign.

2. The Property Is Dirty or Smells Strongly of Urine or Feces

Dogs can certainly create messes, but a well-run facility should still be clean and sanitary. Strong odors, dirty bedding, overflowing trash, or unsanitary food and water bowls suggest poor daily care.

3. The Dogs Already There Look Stressed

Pay attention to the animals already in their care. Dogs that appear frightened, withdrawn, excessively anxious, or ignored may be telling you more than the staff ever will.

4. Caregivers Seem Impatient or Rough

Watch how the staff speaks to and handles the dogs. Kind, patient caregivers create calm dogs. Yelling, grabbing collars harshly, or acting frustrated are behaviors that should concern you.

5. They Can't Answer Basic Questions

Professional pet sitters should confidently explain their routines, emergency procedures, feeding schedules, medication protocols, and experience. Vague answers or inconsistent information are red flags.

6. The Yard Doesn't Look Safe

Broken fencing, gates that don't latch securely, standing water, dangerous debris, or areas where a dog could escape are all reasons to keep looking.

7. There Doesn't Seem to Be Enough Staff

If one person appears overwhelmed while caring for many dogs, your pet may not receive the attention they deserve. Every dog should be supervised appropriately and never left unattended for long periods.

8. They Don't Ask Questions About Your Dog

One of the biggest signs of an excellent pet sitter is curiosity. They should want to know your dog's medical needs, medications, fears, favorite activities, daily routine, and personality. If they don't ask, they may not provide individualized care.

9. Communication Is Poor

If it's difficult to get a return phone call before you've even booked, imagine trying to reach them while you're hundreds of miles away. Clear communication before your trip usually reflects good communication during your trip.

10. Your Gut Says Something Is Off

Sometimes you can't explain it—you just don't feel comfortable. Listen to that feeling. Your dog depends on you to make good decisions on their behalf. If something feels wrong, continue your search until you find someone who gives you complete confidence.

One Last Thought

The right pet sitter won't just care for your dog—they'll care about your dog. They will welcome your questions, respect your concerns, and treat your pet like family. Taking a little extra time to find that person can make all the difference, allowing you to enjoy your travels knowing your best friend is safe, loved, and well cared for until you return home.

Become a subscriber and get your free Pet Care Checklist! You'll have everything you need to ensure your dog is happy and safe while you're away. You'll also be sent my free Ultimate Survival Travel planner and workbook. If you think I missed something, or want more information, email me at nessa@singlesickbroketraveler.com and I'll get back to you!

Me on an outing with my dogs and my dog clients

The Single, Sick & Broke Traveler

Travel stories for the brave and budget-conscious.

Contact Me!

nessa@singlesickbroketraveler.com

© 2025. All rights reserved.